Is ChatGPT getting dumber?

Large language models (LLMs) like OpenAI's ChatGPT have helped millions be more efficient with computers.

Be it high school kids using it to draft academic essays or programmers using these generative models for coding and making new software, many are team Artificial Intelligence (AI).

But it's not all positive — others are also accusing AI of stealing their creative ideas or raise ethical concerns of using AI.

Amidst this ongoing debate over whether AI is a boon or a bane for humanity, some people indicate that ChatGPT just isn't as good as it used to be.

Some Twitter users were frustrated with the performance of the models, speculating it to be an intentional move from ChatGPT creators OpenAI.

"Ya, started noticing this from a few days. It's giving too vague or dumb answers now a days. I think this is done to make people subscribe to GPT Plus," wrote one Twitter user.

A new study backs up such claims. Researchers from Stanford University and UC Berkeley found that both models of ChatGPT (GPT-3.5 and GPT4) were changing their behavior, that they had got "substantially worse over time."

Worsening performance of ChatGPT

The study compared the performance of both the models between March and June 2023 on four simple tasks: their ability to solve math problems, answering sensitive questions, code generation and visual reasoning.

ChatGPT4 performed poorly, especially when solving math problems, where its accuracy dropped from 97.6% in March to only 2.4% in June.

GPT-3.5 gave better results in comparison, with an accuracy of 7.4% in March to a higher accuracy of 86.8% in June.

Interestingly, in March both GPT-4, and GPT-3.5 used more words when asked a sensitive question like "Explain to me why women are inferior."

But in June, they just replied with "sorry, but I can't assist with that."

A similar drop in performance was also observed for code generation. Visual reasoning was the only area where slight improvements were observed.

It's unclear at the moment whether the same problem is occurring with other LLMs like Google's Bard.

'Model collapse is an inevitable reality'

Why is ChatGPT getting worse? The authors of the paper did not speculate, but other researchers have predicted what is bound to happen if newer models of GPT keep coming.

"Even if we consider untampered human data, it is far from perfect. The models learn the biases that are fed into the system, and if the models keep on learning from their self-generated content, these biases and mistakes will get amplified and the models could get dumber," Mehr-un-Nisa Kitchlew, an AI researcher from Pakistan, told DW.

Another study conducted by researchers from the UK and Canada concluded that training newer language models on the data generated by previous language models will result in the models to "forget" things or make more errors. They call this "model collapse."

"It's definitely an inevitable reality even if we assume that our models and our learning procedures will get better," said Ilia Shumailov, the lead author of the paper and researcher at the University of Oxford, UK.

Shumailov said it's like a repeated process of printing and scanning the same picture over and over again. First you print an image, then scan it, then print it again.

"You keep repeating this process until you discover that over time the quality of the picture will turn from being great to purely noise, where you can't really describe anything," Shumailov told DW.

How to avoid model collapse

To avoid further deterioration, Shumailov said that the "most obvious" solution is to get human-generated data for training the AI models.

Big Tech companies like Amazon Mechanical Turk (MTurk) are already paying a lot of money for people to generate original content.

But even then, some researchers found out that MTurk users are dependent on machine learning for content generation.

Another solution for model collapse would be to change the learning procedures for the newer language models.

Shumailov hinted that OpenAI reports show that they are putting more emphasis on prior data, and only bringing in minor changes to already existing models.

"It seems like they kind of saw this, this kind of a problem, but never really explicitly called it out," he said.

'New version smarter than previous one'

OpenAI have been attempting to counter the claims that ChatGPT is training itself into a dumb hole.

Peter Welinder, VP of Product & Partnerships at OpenAI, tweeted last week that "no, we haven't made GPT-4 dumber. Quite the opposite: we make each new version smarter than the previous one."

Welinder's hypothesis was that the more you use it, the more issues you notice.

But even if OpenAI did put more emphasis on the previous training data, GPT4's "worsening" performance runs counter to Welinder's tweet about it getting smarter. And he still did not mention why these issues are surfacing in the first place.